Showing posts with label Flint. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Flint. Show all posts
Saturday, April 3, 2010
Does Ann Arbor Have a Fire Bug?
Overnight last night, there were three fires in Ann Arbor. All began outside student housing. All are under investigation. The most serious, which began on the porch of a rental house, sent three people to the hospital. One, Eastern Michigan University senior Renden LeMaster, subsequently died. To put this in some perspective, during 2006 (the most recent statistics I could find), the Ann Arbor Fire Department responded to 322 fire calls, less than one a day, and many of these were for situations that did not require them to put out a fire (e.g. burnt toast). So three is a lot, and someoned dying is a very big deal.
There are two pieces of context that are important in understanding how people are thinking about this. The first is that yesterday afternoon and evening the National Weather Service had issued a Fire Weather Watch for southeast Michigan. The weather was unseasonably warm and dry with high wind, meaning that conditions were ripe for fires to start and for small fires to become big ones. The other is that about 50 miles away in the city of Flint, as I wrote earlier this week, there have been about 40 arson fires in the last three weeks.
Either one of these two factors could stand alone and swing how we feel about the fires last night. If there was the weather alert and no situation in Flint, people might be thinking this was a string of terrible accidents exacerbated by the weather. If there were a firebug in Flint and no weather alert, we might be sure this was arson. As it is, we have both of those things, so you might expect people to reflect a balance in their thinking.
If that's what you expected, you would be wrong. The news coverage has made no mention of the weather alert at all. It has been fairly restrained, on the other hand, in pointing to arson. However, all of the news stories mention that the fires are "under investigation" and that one of them -- not the house fire, but one in which the fire started with a car that had not been driven in a few days -- is considered suspicious. A commenter posted something about the fires in Flint almost as soon as the first story about last night's fires in Ann Arbor went up. The University of Michigan has issued a crime bulletin which, paradoxically, describes "several fires" as being "under investigation," but then tells community members to make sure their cigarettes are fully extinguished.
So, why isn't there more balance in people's thinking? In the hours after an incident, balance is not what we're wired for. We are wired to consider the worst. This is a survival instinct. When something awful happens, we don't want to miss something that might point out that there is more danger ahead, so we are skittish. If someone has been shot, every car backfiring or door slamming sounds like a shot. If there has been a car accident, every driver seems a little erratic. And if there has been a fire, every fire might be arson. Add in the media's natural tendency to go for the sensational, and we don't have a prayer of having any sense of perspective on this.
It's entirely possible these were all arson fires. It's much more likely that one or two were and the other(s) were accidental. It is very unlikely that there is a new serial firebug in Ann Arbor, as there is in Flint, although of course time will tell. It's a good time to remember to check smoke detectors and escape routes, but it's also a good time to remember that while a rash of arson fires affecting us personally is possible, it still isn't likely.
Thursday, April 1, 2010
Arson and Layoffs in Flint
On March 24, the city of Flint, Michigan announced that it would be laying off 23 firefighters and 46 police officers the next day. Within minutes of the press conference, an arson fire broke out in a vacant building. In the nine days since, there have been nearly 40 such fires, including five last night alone. Three firefighters have been injured. Flint has asked for mutual aid, a system under which cities and towns agree to help each other in an emergency, from other county fire departments. Now those departments are starting to cancel their mutual aid agreements because they, too, are stretched thin.
No one knows for sure who is starting the fires. Many have speculated that they are a protest against the layoffs. Some have gone further and accused firefighters of setting them. The head of the firefighter's union has said he is truly insulted by that accusation, and that he does not believe the layoffs and the fires are connected at all. It is always possible that this is a horrible coincidence.
Layoffs can be very distressing to people in any profession. In a profession, like firefighting, where colleagues are closely knit, it is especially difficult. Unless you know or are a firefighter, it's difficult to imagine how much these men and women rely on each other and bond together. Layoffs represent a separation of one or members of, essentially, the family. It's a grotesque understatement to say that that is bad for morale.
On the other hand, you might expect that firefighters don't mind a string of fires. After all, putting out fires is what they do. Most firefighters will tell you, however, that while they like their work and are glad to be able to help the community, they don't actually want there to be a lot of fires. Like most emergency workers, they like being able to make a difference, but they wish they didn't have to. What's more, every fire represents a danger to the firefighters who respond. Any fire could become dangerous or even lethal. In that sense, every one of the arson fires in Flint is an intentional assault on the fire department.
In addition to the double-whammy of layoffs and the fires, we now have other departments saying that they will not come to Flint to help. I'm certainly not in a position to criticize those decisions -- every city has to do what makes sense for their people and their community. To the Flint fire department, however, this just adds insult to injury. People who go through critical incidents often feel helpless. The sense of not being able to do anything is horrible. Asking for help and not getting it greatly complicates the situation. Imagine someone who is assaulted in broad daylight while passersby ignore it. Their reaction may have as much to do with being ignored as with the assault. Now the Flint firefighters are being assaulted repeatedly, and neighboring cities are saying they will no longer help.
I don't know who's setting the fires in Flint, or what their motivation is. I will say that if they are motivated by support for the firefighters and protest of the layoffs, their actions are truly counter productive. They have taken a situation that would be hard under the best of circumstances, and escalated it severely. With friends like this, the firefighters in Flint sure don't need enemies.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Meet the Quarterback
- Naomi Zikmund-Fisher
- is a clinical social worker, former school Principal and a Crisis Consultant for schools and community organizations. You can learn more about her at www.SchoolCrisisConsultant.com
Subscribe
Posts
All Comments