Showing posts with label insurance coverage. Show all posts
Showing posts with label insurance coverage. Show all posts
Thursday, June 18, 2009
Paramedics for the Mind
Last weekend, a glider crashed on takeoff from an airfield in Unadilla Township, Michigan, which is in Livingston County, or the next county over from Ann Arbor, if that means anything to you. A passenger was killed and the pilot seriously injured.
When something like this (and by this I mean any kind of messy event such as a car crash, a suicide, or an industrial accident) happens, EMS and fire and police descend upon the scene. Physical injuries are given first aid and people taken to the hospital. The authorities conduct their investigation. And then those affected -- the victims themselves, the people nearby, the businesses, the neighbors -- are left to their own devices.
I don't know whether crisis intervention services were given to the employees of that airfield, where they have had five crashes, two of them fatal, in the last three years, or to the people who live near the airfield. I also don't know if they needed them. But they sure might have.
Many communities these days have Critical Incident Stress Management (CISM) teams that work with civilians. CISM got its start with first responders, and that's still the setting where it is implemented the most systematically, but more and more towns, cities, counties and states are recognizing a need for early crisis intervention in the community. The Monday Morning Crisis Quarterback herself serves on the Traumatic Event Response Network (TERN) for Washtenaw County, Michigan.
However, if your community is like my community, the team doesn't get notified of every event, and we don't "chase cases." We respond when we're asked to. Which requires that people know about us. And I'd venture to guess that if you grabbed 100 people off the street in our county and asked them about crisis response teams, at least 95 of them wouldn't have a clue what you were talking about. In practice, this means that we respond to events where someone involved is or is close to a first responder, where first responders are very much affected and their team (which is coordinated out of the same office) contacts ours, when someone on the team is close to the situation, or when someone knows there must be resources out there, and starts asking around.
This is emblematic of how we think about mental health in our society. Mental health care is not seen as a necessity unless the situation is life threatening. Even those with good insurance tend to have lousy mental health insurance. Traumatic stress is seen as an after-effect, not a primary injury, and so early intervention is not the norm -- we wait to see how people are doing.
Can you imagine if we treated blows to the head the way we treat traumatic stress? We would say, "well, it's possible that you'll have some problems if you have a concussion, so go home and if you don't feel right later, go see a specialist. Your insurance probably won't cover it, by the way." Can you imagine the lawsuits when people started to die? We understand that head injuries need to be evaluated immediately because they can lead to life-threatening problems. Why don't we understand the same about traumatic exposure?
Last month I was sitting in an airport waiting for a plane to go to a conference of the International Critical Incident Stress Foundation (ICISF). I was chatting with a man nearby, having the usual, "why are you traveling" discussions. I told him that I am a school administrator and I respond to schools following traumatic events, and he of course made the connection to Columbine. He said, "I don't know what the point of responding is. You just have to say, these kids were crazy, get over it." Then he paused and said, "If you actually saw those shootings, it would mess you up for the rest of your life."
This, too, is the problem with how we look at traumatic stress. We view prevention and/or early intervention as pointless, we tell people to "get over it," and then we accept permanent damage to the psyche as inevitable. Can't we do things a different way?
I envision a world where 911 dispatches CISM the way they dispatch the fire department to a known fire -- if the incident is at all traumatic, someone from the CISM team goes and evaluates the need for a response. Not everything needs it, just like sometimes the fire department shows up and the fire's already out. But couldn't we make it available to everyone, somehow? People like those folks who work at or live near the airfield should not think for a moment they need to go it alone.
When something like this (and by this I mean any kind of messy event such as a car crash, a suicide, or an industrial accident) happens, EMS and fire and police descend upon the scene. Physical injuries are given first aid and people taken to the hospital. The authorities conduct their investigation. And then those affected -- the victims themselves, the people nearby, the businesses, the neighbors -- are left to their own devices.
I don't know whether crisis intervention services were given to the employees of that airfield, where they have had five crashes, two of them fatal, in the last three years, or to the people who live near the airfield. I also don't know if they needed them. But they sure might have.
Many communities these days have Critical Incident Stress Management (CISM) teams that work with civilians. CISM got its start with first responders, and that's still the setting where it is implemented the most systematically, but more and more towns, cities, counties and states are recognizing a need for early crisis intervention in the community. The Monday Morning Crisis Quarterback herself serves on the Traumatic Event Response Network (TERN) for Washtenaw County, Michigan.
However, if your community is like my community, the team doesn't get notified of every event, and we don't "chase cases." We respond when we're asked to. Which requires that people know about us. And I'd venture to guess that if you grabbed 100 people off the street in our county and asked them about crisis response teams, at least 95 of them wouldn't have a clue what you were talking about. In practice, this means that we respond to events where someone involved is or is close to a first responder, where first responders are very much affected and their team (which is coordinated out of the same office) contacts ours, when someone on the team is close to the situation, or when someone knows there must be resources out there, and starts asking around.
This is emblematic of how we think about mental health in our society. Mental health care is not seen as a necessity unless the situation is life threatening. Even those with good insurance tend to have lousy mental health insurance. Traumatic stress is seen as an after-effect, not a primary injury, and so early intervention is not the norm -- we wait to see how people are doing.
Can you imagine if we treated blows to the head the way we treat traumatic stress? We would say, "well, it's possible that you'll have some problems if you have a concussion, so go home and if you don't feel right later, go see a specialist. Your insurance probably won't cover it, by the way." Can you imagine the lawsuits when people started to die? We understand that head injuries need to be evaluated immediately because they can lead to life-threatening problems. Why don't we understand the same about traumatic exposure?
Last month I was sitting in an airport waiting for a plane to go to a conference of the International Critical Incident Stress Foundation (ICISF). I was chatting with a man nearby, having the usual, "why are you traveling" discussions. I told him that I am a school administrator and I respond to schools following traumatic events, and he of course made the connection to Columbine. He said, "I don't know what the point of responding is. You just have to say, these kids were crazy, get over it." Then he paused and said, "If you actually saw those shootings, it would mess you up for the rest of your life."
This, too, is the problem with how we look at traumatic stress. We view prevention and/or early intervention as pointless, we tell people to "get over it," and then we accept permanent damage to the psyche as inevitable. Can't we do things a different way?
I envision a world where 911 dispatches CISM the way they dispatch the fire department to a known fire -- if the incident is at all traumatic, someone from the CISM team goes and evaluates the need for a response. Not everything needs it, just like sometimes the fire department shows up and the fire's already out. But couldn't we make it available to everyone, somehow? People like those folks who work at or live near the airfield should not think for a moment they need to go it alone.
Wednesday, June 17, 2009
More on Flight 1549: What you don't know can hurt you
I once taught a mini-elective for upper elementary and middle school students on writing opinion pieces. We generated a list of what made a piece effective, and included that the piece should consider the opposing opinion and respond to what someone who disagrees might say. Then the kids went off to start composing. One student was writing about his support for gay marriage. He wrote, "Gay people should be allowed to get married. It's the right thing to do." I reminded him to respond to what someone who disagreed to him might say, so he added, "Anyone who disagrees with me is a moron."
The Monday Morning Crisis Quarterback thought of this yesterday when, after writing my piece about Tess Sosa's fight to get insurance coverage for her therapy following the crash of US Airways Flight 1549 on the Hudson River, when I stumbled upon an entry at Plastic Surgery 101 on the same topic. In a post entitled "Exhibit A in Why We Will Never Be Able to Control Health Care Costs," Dr. Rob Oliver, Jr., a plastic surgeon in Alabama, writes:
Now, to be fair, Dr. Oliver and I are both guilty of not responding to the opposing point of view, although we did not go so far as to state the other is a moron (at least not yet!). So I would like to address what he has to say a little more fully.
PTSD is, indeed, unprovable. So is pretty much every psychiatric disorder. There is no blood test for schizophrenia, depression, bipolar disorder or PTSD. That doesn't mean they don't exist. And if I were Ms. Sosa and I was interested in going after AIG to milk whatever I could out of a deep pocket, don't you think I'd be going for cash? I can't imagine someone saying, "Gee, you know what I really want? Not a car, not a house, not financial security, no, what I want is some EMDR."
Dr. Oliver goes on to question why the insurer is liable at all, since this was an "act of God," (presuming, here, that the same supernatural force that produces earthquakes and lightning produces massive flocks of geese, which I think is fair). Without looking at the policy, it's hard to know whether this incident as a whole is covered. The standard, though, should be whether physical injuries to passengers would be covered. As I said yesterday, if a broken leg is covered, then psychotherapy should be covered. If a broken leg isn't covered, however, then of course neither should mental health care be covered. All I'm suggesting is that we have parity. I'm guessing we don't.
Trauma reactions are real, and in some cases they are really serious. Someone with untreated PTSD is a ticking time bomb, whether it's a vet who shoots in a crowd or a plane crash survivor who crashes her car into yours. Presuming it isn't real and that people are faking is a very good way to increase the death toll from traumatic events, via homicide or suicide.
Oh, and I just have to say. A plastic surgeon blaming a PTSD patient seeking treatment for the rise in healthcare costs because that treatment may be unnecessary? People who live in glass houses . . .
The Monday Morning Crisis Quarterback thought of this yesterday when, after writing my piece about Tess Sosa's fight to get insurance coverage for her therapy following the crash of US Airways Flight 1549 on the Hudson River, when I stumbled upon an entry at Plastic Surgery 101 on the same topic. In a post entitled "Exhibit A in Why We Will Never Be Able to Control Health Care Costs," Dr. Rob Oliver, Jr., a plastic surgeon in Alabama, writes:
You think Mrs. Sosa and other passengers would count their blessing to be alive and be thrilled with the $5000 check US Airways issued each passenger in compensation (which they didn't even an obligation to do). Apparently this was not acceptable to Mrs. Sosa who is demanding the airlines insurer, A.I.G., pay for all costs associated with her psychotherapy for post traumatic stress disorder, the unprovable sinkhole of psychiatric diagnoses.
Now, to be fair, Dr. Oliver and I are both guilty of not responding to the opposing point of view, although we did not go so far as to state the other is a moron (at least not yet!). So I would like to address what he has to say a little more fully.
PTSD is, indeed, unprovable. So is pretty much every psychiatric disorder. There is no blood test for schizophrenia, depression, bipolar disorder or PTSD. That doesn't mean they don't exist. And if I were Ms. Sosa and I was interested in going after AIG to milk whatever I could out of a deep pocket, don't you think I'd be going for cash? I can't imagine someone saying, "Gee, you know what I really want? Not a car, not a house, not financial security, no, what I want is some EMDR."
Dr. Oliver goes on to question why the insurer is liable at all, since this was an "act of God," (presuming, here, that the same supernatural force that produces earthquakes and lightning produces massive flocks of geese, which I think is fair). Without looking at the policy, it's hard to know whether this incident as a whole is covered. The standard, though, should be whether physical injuries to passengers would be covered. As I said yesterday, if a broken leg is covered, then psychotherapy should be covered. If a broken leg isn't covered, however, then of course neither should mental health care be covered. All I'm suggesting is that we have parity. I'm guessing we don't.
Trauma reactions are real, and in some cases they are really serious. Someone with untreated PTSD is a ticking time bomb, whether it's a vet who shoots in a crowd or a plane crash survivor who crashes her car into yours. Presuming it isn't real and that people are faking is a very good way to increase the death toll from traumatic events, via homicide or suicide.
Oh, and I just have to say. A plastic surgeon blaming a PTSD patient seeking treatment for the rise in healthcare costs because that treatment may be unnecessary? People who live in glass houses . . .
Tuesday, June 16, 2009
Flight 1549: The Passengers
Last week, the Monday Morning Crisis Quarterback brought you thoughts on the experiences of the crew of US Airways Flight 1549. Today, we look at the passengers. More specifically, we look at the experience of Tess Sosa, who, according to Keith Olbermann at MSNBC, was on board the flight that landed in the Hudson in January with her husband and two children.
If Olbermann's report is accurate, and frankly it sounds about what you would expect, when Ms. Sosa contacted the insurer for US Airways seeking insurance coverage for mental health therapy for herself and one of her children relating to the trauma of the accident, the person she spoke to hadn't a clue what she was calling about. Then the insurance company told her to use her private insurance. Then they offered to cover three, but only three, mental health visits. And of course, they keep changing who the contact person is. Oh, and for frosting on the cake, the insurer is AIG.
This is one of those stories that could appear on any number of blogs. It takes a critical incident (which is why the Quarterback is interested) and mixes it in with poor customer service, the mess that is dealing with health insurers, the complete failure of the American medical system to deal in any way that makes sense with mental health issues. Then for fun you throw in the financial crisis and government bailouts. This thing ought to be all over the airwaves. But of course, it isn't. I'm not going to go on about why it isn't, but I am going to comment on Ms. Sosa's continued need for mental health care.
As my regular readers know, one of the best predictors of traumatic stress symptoms is believing that you or your loved one is about to die. Ms. Sosa certainly believed, as the plane was going down, that she was going to die. In fact, statistics indicate that she was more likely to be right than wrong on that one. There aren't all that many plane crash survivors walking the earth these days. She had her husband and two children with her, and she also believed they would die.
Once the plane "landed" on the river, water came in through the tail section of the plane. The passengers and crew evacuated onto the wings and into the water, which was cold. As she was pulled out of the water, she looked back and saw her husband holding one of their children above the water line. She had every reason to believe they might not make it.
I have no idea what immediate crisis support was given to the passengers on this flight. I also have no way of knowing whether more or different early intervention would have helped Ms. Sosa (there is lots of evidence to show that CISM reduces alcohol use and depression, but it isn't intended to magically ward off PTSD). Statistically, it's likely that some percentage of the passengers would need to be referred for further care and some of them wouldn't. Ms. Sosa did, and she's trying to get the help she needs. Good for her.
Ms. Sosa was injured in that accident, just as surely as if she had broken her leg or her nose. And she needs treatment, just as surely as if she needed surgery or physical therapy. Even in the arbitrary world of mental health insurance, three sessions is arbitrarily short. Five with the possibility of renewal would be much more the norm (and that's probably not sufficient coverage for a lot of folks, either).
AIG should thank its lucky stars they aren't paying hefty death benefits to the families of those who were on that plane, suck it up, and cover their mental health treatment. It's just plain the right thing to do.
If Olbermann's report is accurate, and frankly it sounds about what you would expect, when Ms. Sosa contacted the insurer for US Airways seeking insurance coverage for mental health therapy for herself and one of her children relating to the trauma of the accident, the person she spoke to hadn't a clue what she was calling about. Then the insurance company told her to use her private insurance. Then they offered to cover three, but only three, mental health visits. And of course, they keep changing who the contact person is. Oh, and for frosting on the cake, the insurer is AIG.
This is one of those stories that could appear on any number of blogs. It takes a critical incident (which is why the Quarterback is interested) and mixes it in with poor customer service, the mess that is dealing with health insurers, the complete failure of the American medical system to deal in any way that makes sense with mental health issues. Then for fun you throw in the financial crisis and government bailouts. This thing ought to be all over the airwaves. But of course, it isn't. I'm not going to go on about why it isn't, but I am going to comment on Ms. Sosa's continued need for mental health care.
As my regular readers know, one of the best predictors of traumatic stress symptoms is believing that you or your loved one is about to die. Ms. Sosa certainly believed, as the plane was going down, that she was going to die. In fact, statistics indicate that she was more likely to be right than wrong on that one. There aren't all that many plane crash survivors walking the earth these days. She had her husband and two children with her, and she also believed they would die.
Once the plane "landed" on the river, water came in through the tail section of the plane. The passengers and crew evacuated onto the wings and into the water, which was cold. As she was pulled out of the water, she looked back and saw her husband holding one of their children above the water line. She had every reason to believe they might not make it.
I have no idea what immediate crisis support was given to the passengers on this flight. I also have no way of knowing whether more or different early intervention would have helped Ms. Sosa (there is lots of evidence to show that CISM reduces alcohol use and depression, but it isn't intended to magically ward off PTSD). Statistically, it's likely that some percentage of the passengers would need to be referred for further care and some of them wouldn't. Ms. Sosa did, and she's trying to get the help she needs. Good for her.
Ms. Sosa was injured in that accident, just as surely as if she had broken her leg or her nose. And she needs treatment, just as surely as if she needed surgery or physical therapy. Even in the arbitrary world of mental health insurance, three sessions is arbitrarily short. Five with the possibility of renewal would be much more the norm (and that's probably not sufficient coverage for a lot of folks, either).
AIG should thank its lucky stars they aren't paying hefty death benefits to the families of those who were on that plane, suck it up, and cover their mental health treatment. It's just plain the right thing to do.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Meet the Quarterback
- Naomi Zikmund-Fisher
- is a clinical social worker, former school Principal and a Crisis Consultant for schools and community organizations. You can learn more about her at www.SchoolCrisisConsultant.com
Contact the Quarterback
Monday Morning Crisis Quarterback on Facebook
Subscribe via email
Quarterback for Kindle