Tuesday, August 4, 2009
Sometimes "Close to Home" Isn't Close . . . Or Home
I was perusing the headlines from CNN before heading off to bed tonight when I saw one that read "5 Die in Gym Shooting Near Pittsburgh." This caught my attention because I lived in Pittsburgh for 9 years and still have dear friends there. I clicked through to the story for more details and found that the shooting was near Bridgeville, where I once worked when I was an itinerant teacher, but where I have no friends now, at a gym that doesn't ring a particular bell for me.
You might think I'd move on to the next story, or at least breathe a sigh of relief. And I guess I was a little relieved to realize that whatever awful thing may have happened didn't happen to anyone I know. I moved out of Pittsburgh more than 7 years ago, so letting this go should have been pretty easy. But the initial "Oh my God" reaction -- both cognitive and the physical "punch to the stomach" feeling -- remained, and I started looking for more information from the Pittsburgh media websites. The most complete and seemingly accurate coverage is from the Pittsburgh Post Gazette.
As I clicked around the web, I started to ask myself what I was looking for? True, I am just a news junkie, and nothing excites a news junkie like breaking news. But I think there are two other things going on. The first is that I was looking for additional confirmation that this didn't have any connection to me. One story wasn't enough. I needed to know it, and know it again. The second is that in the split second after I read that first headline, this story became mine even though it didn't have to be. I connected with it. And now, the fact that I don't know the victims or the perpetrator doesn't matter, because I've connected with the fact that someone knows them, and someone got that punch to the stomach and found out it was someone they know.
So what do you call this phenomenon? Secondary trauma is when you are traumatized by hearing about someone else's trauma. Perhaps it's that on a small scale. Countertransference is the over-identification, positively or negatively, with the people you're helping, but I'm not helping these people. I guess I would just say that this one hit a little too close to home, even though it's hundreds of miles away from my home. Sometimes your mind just works that way.
You might think I'd move on to the next story, or at least breathe a sigh of relief. And I guess I was a little relieved to realize that whatever awful thing may have happened didn't happen to anyone I know. I moved out of Pittsburgh more than 7 years ago, so letting this go should have been pretty easy. But the initial "Oh my God" reaction -- both cognitive and the physical "punch to the stomach" feeling -- remained, and I started looking for more information from the Pittsburgh media websites. The most complete and seemingly accurate coverage is from the Pittsburgh Post Gazette.
As I clicked around the web, I started to ask myself what I was looking for? True, I am just a news junkie, and nothing excites a news junkie like breaking news. But I think there are two other things going on. The first is that I was looking for additional confirmation that this didn't have any connection to me. One story wasn't enough. I needed to know it, and know it again. The second is that in the split second after I read that first headline, this story became mine even though it didn't have to be. I connected with it. And now, the fact that I don't know the victims or the perpetrator doesn't matter, because I've connected with the fact that someone knows them, and someone got that punch to the stomach and found out it was someone they know.
So what do you call this phenomenon? Secondary trauma is when you are traumatized by hearing about someone else's trauma. Perhaps it's that on a small scale. Countertransference is the over-identification, positively or negatively, with the people you're helping, but I'm not helping these people. I guess I would just say that this one hit a little too close to home, even though it's hundreds of miles away from my home. Sometimes your mind just works that way.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Meet the Quarterback
- Naomi Zikmund-Fisher
- is a clinical social worker, former school Principal and a Crisis Consultant for schools and community organizations. You can learn more about her at www.SchoolCrisisConsultant.com
Contact the Quarterback
Monday Morning Crisis Quarterback on Facebook
Subscribe via email
Quarterback for Kindle
Blog Archive
-
▼
2009
(185)
-
▼
August
(31)
- The Station Fire
- Ask the Question: Suicide in the Workplace
- H1N1: When the News Isn't Scary, They Just Make i...
- Hurricane Katrina and the Help That Never Came
- Waking Up From a Nightmare You've Gotten Used To
- When Your Hero Dies
- Is 90,000 a Lot?
- What If It Is Your Fault?
- Getting Back on the Horse
- Harrison High School's Football Plane Crash
- Why the Press Doesn't Get It
- The Ghosts of Virginia Tech
- Tom Barrett's Recovery
- The Trouble With "Closure"
- "You Didn't Do the Best You Could"
- The Trauma of Being a Hero
- CISM (Or Lack Thereof) at the Lockheed Wildfire
- Why I Don't Usually Update Stories
- The Quarterback's 10 Commandments of H1N1 Crisis C...
- Friendly Fire
- The Latest from the Government on H1N1
- Grief, Trauma and Traumatic Grief
- What Makes an Incident a "Bad One"
- Aviation Over the Hudson
- The New CDC H1N1 Guidance for Schools
- Sharing Our Trauma: The Pittsburgh Gym Shootings
- Quick -- How Lethal is H1N1?
- Sometimes "Close to Home" Isn't Close . . . Or Home
- H1N1: Sound the Alarm! Or not . . .
- Rest in Peace, Captain Speicher
- Update: Suspect in Provost Murder Completes Suicide
-
▼
August
(31)
0 comments:
Post a Comment